Why is it that we (by that I mean society on the internet as a whole) see Google as being a company filled with “The Good Guys”? Why do we always see them as so much kinder, gentler, and better than Yahoo! and Microsoft, their two main competitors?
Honestly, it?s not like they?re really any different. All three entities are corporations designed to make money, and all three (albeit more-so Google and Microsoft) are industry leaders in their fields.
So really, what makes Google the hippie-friendly, world peace-loving, three-hugging good guys and at the same time makes Microsoft the evil, unholy, satanic pig of a corporation that represents the physical embodiment of all that is evil in the world?
Is it simply that Microsoft is better known for their incredibly highly priced monopolistic software and related security attitudes and policies? What if you just disregard all that? Google doesn?t compete with Microsoft in the desktop operating system or client-side software markets, so you?re really comparing apples and oranges if that?s involved in your argument.
SO if we just compare the internet services divisions of Microsoft to Google, what other arguments do we have in favor of Google?
Well, there?s GMail, the largest offering for web-based mail offered by any mainstream provider, and all for free.
So Hotmail doesn?t give you that much space for free? so what? Honestly, find someone who has even used 1/3 of the 2gb they?re allotted for their GMail account and I?ll concede the point, but the fact of the matter is, no one (certainly not the average user) is going to use that much space for just their email… ever.
Alright, well, Hotmail also has lots of advertisements on all their pages, but GMail is nice and clean. Well, how else do you expect Microsoft to have provided this service for free for so long (10 years) totally for free? How is Google doing it without all the ads then? Well, let?s just say there is definitely something in it for them…
SO now we?ve covered GMail… What else is there? The only other product Microsoft has of any size or importance that is in direct competition with Google is their MSN search engine itself. I know hundreds of people personally who swear by Google?s search and despise MSN, but is there really any valid reason? Even if you did say that Google returned “better” results, your arguments would be purely subjective, because there?s no real way to objectively measure or compare search engines and their results.
Can anyone really come up with a reason Microsoft is hated and Google is loved? I mean, Google seems to be looking a little shadier to me lately… But maybe that really is just me…
Personally, I?d really love to get an opinion from Mark Jen on the matter, since he?s worked for both companies in the past year.
Anyone have any compelling arguments for / against one company or another? I could come up with some more on my own, but it?d turn into a 10 page rant, and that?s not what I want out of this entry.
Comments? Rebuttals? Drop me an email, or leave me a comment here for the world to see…